You are here
Home ›Bosnian Revolt: Nationalism, "Democracy" and Class
It may not last long but there is something positive about the struggles that began in Bosnia last week. The original issue was over the privatisation of 5 factories in the Tuzla Canton. These were Dita, Polihem, Poliolhem, GUMARA and Konjuh. Privatisation in the past have been followed by shutdowns. Not unusual in ex-Yugoslavia the factor that sparked things off was the vicious response of the police.
Overall police repression was really severe and it was one of the triggers for these riots. There are numerous videos showing police beating up people, throwing rocks at them or throwing them in a river (1).
It was the last straw for many.
On February 7, Bosnia was on its feet protesting against corrupt government, unemployment and the overall social situation. The situation erupted and masses were on the streets. In Tuzla, police surrendered to protestors, laid down their shields, helmets and batons, and let the masses storm the buildings. Protestors burned down the headquarters of Tuzla’s City Assembly and that of the City Administration (2).
In the wake of these protests the local prime minister offered to resign as a set of demands were incorporated into a “proclamation” issued by the “Plenum” of “workers and citizens of Tuzla Canton”. This called for the privatisations to be rescinded and the factories to be started up again. It then added calls for equal wages of functionaries with workers, a new government of technocrats whose work would be monitored weekly by all “interested citizens”, control of policing, and end to payments for ex-ministers (3).
Now we could say that this or that measure in the list is not very promising but many of them echo the kinds of things that the Paris Commune was trying to implement 150 years ago. And we should remember too that this is the initial stages of a movement in a territory that not so long ago was tortured by civil war, ethnic cleansing and imperialist intervention (4). There is no mention of nationalism so who knows, it could develop in an autonomous working class direction. Or it could yet be captured by some other capitalist faction which demands only a reform of the political system. Recent history hitherto says the latter is overwhelming favourite but at some point history always turns so we cannot rule out the development of an independent working class movement. There is some promise here.
In Mostar, protesters stormed and burned down the headquarters of the Herzego-Neretvanian government. After that, they burned down with Molotov cocktails the headquarters of the City Administration, the Croatian Democratic Union’s and the Party of Democratic Action’s HQs. Police didn’t intervene, because in the last few months they haven’t chosen a director of regional police, who is the only person that can activate Special Forces. In these demonstrations, protestors from “both sides of the river” (i.e., both Bosniaks and Croats) participated.
Juraj Katalenac op cit
The parties whose offices were attacked are noted for their nationalist stances and the fact that not only Bosniaks and Croats but even the Serbs of Banja Luka are now involved is also promising. We wrote recently about the dead-end of nationalism in the Ukraine. After the collapse of the Stalinist state capitalist apparatus and the wars which followed in the Balkans in the 1990s, Eastern Europe as a whole has become almost synonymous with a rabid nationalism of the ethnic cleansing variety. There is nothing like a bloody war for reinforcing nationalist notions of difference. There is nothing better than nationalism, racism and chauvinism in wiping out the elementary solidarity of those who work alongside each other at the same level. Ruling classes everywhere play the nationalist card to destroy out all notions of class solidarity. So the recent riots in Bosnia stand out. They demonstrate that all the propaganda in the world cannot put the class genie back in the bottle once the crisis and its effects are generalised.
Bosnia’s Economic Crisis
And Bosnia is facing an enormous economic crisis. The Bosnian economic model was based on capital inflows but after the speculative bubble burst in 2008 they virtually stopped. Juraj Katalenac sums up the situation
When we are talking about Bosnia, people usually like to emphasise only problems related to national identity, while they “forget” social ones. Bosnia is in a really big economic crisis, that has highly enhanced austerity measures and flexibilization of the labour market, along with well-known problems of 1990s privatization, incredibly high unemployment (44 percent of workers are unemployed!) and a high number of workers that work and don’t receive salaries. The privatization of companies in ex-Yugoslav countries usually resulted in companies’ bankruptcy and workers losing their jobs, as new owners were not interested in investing in companies, but only in “sucking out” capital and surplus as fast as possible.
The level of class hatred against the bosses and the politicians who became rich on working class misery is enormous. After the riots the ruling class was not slow to react.
These riots didn’t just wake up the workers of Bosnia, but they also woke up the bourgeoisie. They’ve seen an authentic movement against them, a movement that was based on social and class issues rather than national ones. And they had to intervene as quickly as possible.
The prime minister resigned and then the propaganda machines of all the nationalist politicians went into full swing denouncing the rioters and trying to incite one group against the next. According to the leaders (Croat, Bosnian or Serb) it was either an EU or US plot or one by Bosniaks wanting a more centralised state than the post-Dayton federal version. The media assault cannot be underestimated in neutralising the movement from spreading further but as the economic situation in ex-Yugoslavia is now dire everywhere the ruling class will have their work cut out to keep up their nationalist offensive. The grafitti that appeared in Tuzla of “Death to All Nationalists” was one sign but there are others.
… while the Serbian vice president issued his calls for stability, the Belgrade Police Union issued a statement where they showed sympathy for social protests in Bosnia, claiming that a similar scenario is possible in Serbia “where there are also many destitute, unemployed, or employed people not receiving salaries, with corruption at all levels and political manipulation of citizens” and threatened to join demonstrations if they appear in Serbia. That should be taken really seriously, considering the industrial struggles of workers in Kraljevo and Vranje that even blocked a highway on February 12 (5).
The Plenum Movement
Meanwhile the movement in Bosnia is being spread via plenums. These originated with Croatian students 5 years ago but are now springing up in towns all over Bosnia. What are plenums? According to one activist;
A plenum is an assembly of all the members of a group. It is a public space for debate. It has no leaders or prohibitions. Decisions are made publicly.… A plenum is not a political party, or an NGO, or a one-person association. A plenum is the real, and the only, democracy (6).
And there is no doubt that they represent something new. Something akin to proletarian democracy as we would like to see it working.
These are extraordinary developments. Every day since the protests began, thousands of citizens in Tuzla, Mostar, Sarajevo, Travnik, Zenica, and other towns meet in public places, where they take turns to address the gathered citizens. At the end of each meeting, a list of concrete demands is drawn up and voted on. Each person gets one vote; there is no option to abstain. So far, government officials have resigned in four cantons while new citizen-led structures are developing in plenums (7).
However they are not yet coherent or consistent. One contradictory idea they have put forward is that technocrats run the government but are only held accountable by the rest. This is like the idea of “spetsy” which the Bolsheviks brought in to fight the civil war 1918-21. People with expert knowledge are useful in giving advice and framing options but to give them the decision-making power undermines the mass organs of democracy (in that case the soviets). Assemblies have to be both sovereign and executive and they should delegate those responsible as well as control them. There are other dangers facing the “plenum movement”. Already we have seen that the origins of this movement lay in the strikes of five factories yet in some if the plenums workers demands are relegated to the bottom of the agenda or are forgotten altogether. The notion that all the plenums are doing is cleaning up “democracy” for the “citizens” and not moving towards a new social and economic as well as political set-up is being pushed by powerful forces. Not least amongst these is the EU and Western media. The Economist welcomed the “moderation” of the plenum organisers (we would call it impressive self-organisation) but then issued what sounds like a warning
… if new leaders emerge and if they focus on realistic demands, something might really change (8).
In short, they should bow down before international capitalism, accept more privatisation and thus job losses and then go back to letting the “leaders” run affairs on behalf of international capital. There is no doubt that the plenum movement has posed a question but it is only the working class within the movement that can answer it. Workers in Bosnia should not be taken in by the repeated lie that “better democracy” can improve their lot. There can be no such thing as “better democracy” without the abolition of the capitalist state and the institution of a classless society based on satisfying real needs. There is no emancipation for us under capitalism. Workers in Bosnia need their own political agenda for class autonomy. In the long run too the Bosnian working class can only kick things off – the rest of the world’s working class have to take up the banner of class war everywhere.
Jock(1) See Juraj Katalenac on insurgentnotes.com or libcom.org. Most of the factual information here is taken from that document or from additional information supplied by the author. The opinions are ours.
(2) See Juraj Katalenac op cit
(3) For the full proclamation see europe-solidaire.org.
(5) op. cit. For more on Kraljevo see bhprotestfiles.wordpress.com
(6) Damir Arsenijević, “What is plenum?”. See also eyewitness accounts on anarchistnews.org
(7) Edin Hajdarpasic aljazeera.com
Start here...
- Navigating the Basics
- Platform
- For Communism
- Introduction to Our History
- CWO Social Media
- IWG Social Media
- Klasbatalo Social Media
- Italian Communist Left
- Russian Communist Left
The Internationalist Communist Tendency consists of (unsurprisingly!) not-for-profit organisations. We have no so-called “professional revolutionaries”, nor paid officials. Our sole funding comes from the subscriptions and donations of members and supporters. Anyone wishing to donate can now do so safely using the Paypal buttons below.
ICT publications are not copyrighted and we only ask that those who reproduce them acknowledge the original source (author and website leftcom.org). Purchasing any of the publications listed (see catalogue) can be done in two ways:
- By emailing us at uk@leftcom.org, us@leftcom.org or ca@leftcom.org and asking for our banking details
- By donating the cost of the publications required via Paypal using the “Donate” buttons
- By cheque made out to "Prometheus Publications" and sending it to the following address: CWO, BM CWO, London, WC1N 3XX
The CWO also offers subscriptions to Revolutionary Perspectives (3 issues) and Aurora (at least 4 issues):
- UK £15 (€18)
- Europe £20 (€24)
- World £25 (€30, $30)
Take out a supporter’s sub by adding £10 (€12) to each sum. This will give you priority mailings of Aurora and other free pamphlets as they are produced.
ICT sections
Basics
- Bourgeois revolution
- Competition and monopoly
- Core and peripheral countries
- Crisis
- Decadence
- Democracy and dictatorship
- Exploitation and accumulation
- Factory and territory groups
- Financialization
- Globalization
- Historical materialism
- Imperialism
- Our Intervention
- Party and class
- Proletarian revolution
- Seigniorage
- Social classes
- Socialism and communism
- State
- State capitalism
- War economics
Facts
- Activities
- Arms
- Automotive industry
- Books, art and culture
- Commerce
- Communications
- Conflicts
- Contracts and wages
- Corporate trends
- Criminal activities
- Disasters
- Discriminations
- Discussions
- Drugs and dependencies
- Economic policies
- Education and youth
- Elections and polls
- Energy, oil and fuels
- Environment and resources
- Financial market
- Food
- Health and social assistance
- Housing
- Information and media
- International relations
- Law
- Migrations
- Pensions and benefits
- Philosophy and religion
- Repression and control
- Science and technics
- Social unrest
- Terrorist outrages
- Transports
- Unemployment and precarity
- Workers' conditions and struggles
History
- 01. Prehistory
- 02. Ancient History
- 03. Middle Ages
- 04. Modern History
- 1800: Industrial Revolution
- 1900s
- 1910s
- 1911-12: Turko-Italian War for Libya
- 1912: Intransigent Revolutionary Fraction of the PSI
- 1912: Republic of China
- 1913: Fordism (assembly line)
- 1914-18: World War I
- 1917: Russian Revolution
- 1918: Abstentionist Communist Fraction of the PSI
- 1918: German Revolution
- 1919-20: Biennio Rosso in Italy
- 1919-43: Third International
- 1919: Hungarian Revolution
- 1930s
- 1931: Japan occupies Manchuria
- 1933-43: New Deal
- 1933-45: Nazism
- 1934: Long March of Chinese communists
- 1934: Miners' uprising in Asturias
- 1934: Workers' uprising in "Red Vienna"
- 1935-36: Italian Army Invades Ethiopia
- 1936-38: Great Purge
- 1936-39: Spanish Civil War
- 1937: International Bureau of Fractions of the Communist Left
- 1938: Fourth International
- 1940s
- 1960s
- 1980s
- 1979-89: Soviet war in Afghanistan
- 1980-88: Iran-Iraq War
- 1982: First Lebanon War
- 1982: Sabra and Chatila
- 1986: Chernobyl disaster
- 1987-93: First Intifada
- 1989: Fall of the Berlin Wall
- 1979-90: Thatcher Government
- 1980: Strikes in Poland
- 1982: Falklands War
- 1983: Foundation of IBRP
- 1984-85: UK Miners' Strike
- 1987: Perestroika
- 1989: Tiananmen Square Protests
- 1990s
- 1991: Breakup of Yugoslavia
- 1991: Dissolution of Soviet Union
- 1991: First Gulf War
- 1992-95: UN intervention in Somalia
- 1994-96: First Chechen War
- 1994: Genocide in Rwanda
- 1999-2000: Second Chechen War
- 1999: Introduction of euro
- 1999: Kosovo War
- 1999: WTO conference in Seattle
- 1995: NATO Bombing in Bosnia
- 2000s
- 2000: Second intifada
- 2001: September 11 attacks
- 2001: Piqueteros Movement in Argentina
- 2001: War in Afghanistan
- 2001: G8 Summit in Genoa
- 2003: Second Gulf War
- 2004: Asian Tsunami
- 2004: Madrid train bombings
- 2005: Banlieue riots in France
- 2005: Hurricane Katrina
- 2005: London bombings
- 2006: Anti-CPE movement in France
- 2006: Comuna de Oaxaca
- 2006: Second Lebanon War
- 2007: Subprime Crisis
- 2008: Onda movement in Italy
- 2008: War in Georgia
- 2008: Riots in Greece
- 2008: Pomigliano Struggle
- 2008: Global Crisis
- 2008: Automotive Crisis
- 2009: Post-election crisis in Iran
- 2009: Israel-Gaza conflict
- 2020s
- 1920s
- 1921-28: New Economic Policy
- 1921: Communist Party of Italy
- 1921: Kronstadt Rebellion
- 1922-45: Fascism
- 1922-52: Stalin is General Secretary of PCUS
- 1925-27: Canton and Shanghai revolt
- 1925: Comitato d'Intesa
- 1926: General strike in Britain
- 1926: Lyons Congress of PCd’I
- 1927: Vienna revolt
- 1928: First five-year plan
- 1928: Left Fraction of the PCd'I
- 1929: Great Depression
- 1950s
- 1970s
- 1969-80: Anni di piombo in Italy
- 1971: End of the Bretton Woods System
- 1971: Microprocessor
- 1973: Pinochet's military junta in Chile
- 1975: Toyotism (just-in-time)
- 1977-81: International Conferences Convoked by PCInt
- 1977: '77 movement
- 1978: Economic Reforms in China
- 1978: Islamic Revolution in Iran
- 1978: South Lebanon conflict
- 2010s
- 2010: Greek debt crisis
- 2011: War in Libya
- 2011: Indignados and Occupy movements
- 2011: Sovereign debt crisis
- 2011: Tsunami and Nuclear Disaster in Japan
- 2011: Uprising in Maghreb
- 2014: Euromaidan
- 2016: Brexit Referendum
- 2017: Catalan Referendum
- 2019: Maquiladoras Struggle
- 2010: Student Protests in UK and Italy
- 2011: War in Syria
- 2013: Black Lives Matter Movement
- 2014: Military Intervention Against ISIS
- 2015: Refugee Crisis
- 2018: Haft Tappeh Struggle
- 2018: Climate Movement
People
- Amadeo Bordiga
- Anton Pannekoek
- Antonio Gramsci
- Arrigo Cervetto
- Bruno Fortichiari
- Bruno Maffi
- Celso Beltrami
- Davide Casartelli
- Errico Malatesta
- Fabio Damen
- Fausto Atti
- Franco Migliaccio
- Franz Mehring
- Friedrich Engels
- Giorgio Paolucci
- Guido Torricelli
- Heinz Langerhans
- Helmut Wagner
- Henryk Grossmann
- Karl Korsch
- Karl Liebknecht
- Karl Marx
- Leon Trotsky
- Lorenzo Procopio
- Mario Acquaviva
- Mauro jr. Stefanini
- Michail Bakunin
- Onorato Damen
- Ottorino Perrone (Vercesi)
- Paul Mattick
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Vladimir Lenin
Politics
- Anarchism
- Anti-Americanism
- Anti-Globalization Movement
- Antifascism and United Front
- Antiracism
- Armed Struggle
- Autonomism and Workerism
- Base Unionism
- Bordigism
- Communist Left Inspired
- Cooperativism and autogestion
- DeLeonism
- Environmentalism
- Fascism
- Feminism
- German-Dutch Communist Left
- Gramscism
- ICC and French Communist Left
- Islamism
- Italian Communist Left
- Leninism
- Liberism
- Luxemburgism
- Maoism
- Marxism
- National Liberation Movements
- Nationalism
- No War But The Class War
- PCInt-ICT
- Pacifism
- Parliamentary Center-Right
- Parliamentary Left and Reformism
- Peasant movement
- Revolutionary Unionism
- Russian Communist Left
- Situationism
- Stalinism
- Statism and Keynesism
- Student Movement
- Titoism
- Trotskyism
- Unionism
Regions
User login
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.